The Porch Light Question: Halloween, Hospitality, and an Open Door

I'll be honest: if it were up to me, I'd turn off the porch light on October 31st and spend a quiet evening at home.

I've never liked Halloween. I don't believe Christians should celebrate or observe it, and I know that's a conviction not every believer shares. I also know what that night does to our house: the doorbell ringing over and over, the costumes, the candy, the chaos. In a home where some of us are wired to need quiet and predictability, Halloween night is a lot.

And yet, I can't get away from this: it's the one night of the year our neighbors come to us.

An Open Door

At the start of this month, I wrote about the ten T's of a disciple-making parent. The last one is Tea: hospitality, fellowship, koinonia. Opening our homes and our tables, the way the early church broke bread in their homes with glad and generous hearts (Acts 2:46).

Most of the year, we have to work to open that door. We plan, invite, clean, cook, and hope people come. On Halloween, the whole community is out walking the streets, ready to talk to strangers. The door is already open.

That's why so many churches, including our home church, have turned the night into trunk or treat in their parking lots. The focus moves away from the darker parts of the holiday and toward safety and community. Families come who would never walk into a church on a Sunday, and the gospel often gets shared. Two of our adult children are helping with it this year.

Our new church plant made a different choice. We're joining a community event, and we'll have our own tent where we can hand out candy (a lot of candy), pray for people, answer their questions about God, and invite our new neighbors to our church's first service in November.

Would I rather be home? Yes. But it seems wrong to ignore an open door.

Hospitality Without Grumbling

Peter wrote, "Show hospitality to one another without grumbling" (1 Peter 4:9). I find it comforting that he had to say "without grumbling." He apparently knew some of us would be grumbling.

Hospitality isn't always comfortable. It's not supposed to be about our comfort. It's about the people God puts in front of us. Jesus didn't wait for the crowds to come to a quiet room; He went where they were. Paul stood in the marketplace in Athens and talked with whoever happened to be there (Acts 17:17).

That doesn't mean every family needs to make the same choice ours did. Christians land in different places on Halloween, and Paul's words fit here: "Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind" (Romans 14:5). If your conviction is to stay home, stay home with a clear conscience. But whatever you decide about the holiday, don't miss the people.

When Your Family Can't Do Crowds

For a mixed-needs family, "just show up" isn't simple. Hospitality has to fit the family God gave you. A few ideas:

• Hospitality doesn't have to happen at your house. If the doorbell is too much for your home, a church booth or community event moves the chaos somewhere else, and you can leave when you need to.

• Serve in shifts. One parent takes a shift at the event while the other stays home with a child who needs quiet. Everyone participates in a way they can manage.

• Give each child a job that fits. Handing out candy, holding the basket, drawing a picture for the booth at home, or praying for the families who come by. A child doesn't have to be in the crowd to be part of the mission.

• Plan the exit before you go. Headphones, a quiet spot in the car, a signal that means "I'm done." Leaving early isn't failure.

• Keep the door open after Halloween. One evening of candy is a start. The real hospitality is the follow-up: the neighbor you met, the family you invite for tea on a calm afternoon when your home can handle a guest.

Your children are watching how you treat the people who come to your door or your tent or your trunk. That's one of the most powerful lessons in discipleship they'll ever get.

Turning the Light On

I'll probably still grumble a little this Saturday. But I'll be present, handing out candy, and praying for whoever God brings by.

Whatever your family does this Halloween, I'd encourage you to ask one question: Who is God putting in front of us, and how can we love them well?

Want more on making faith part of your family's everyday life? Join the mailing list for each new post and the monthly newsletter. Find it toward the bottom of this page: https://terriehellardbrown.com/