
This post was originally sent in my monthly newsletter.
I loved my mom so much. She was one of my best friends later in life. However, when I was little, she criticized me all the time telling me I was too shy and negative. Then, one day I was feeling amazing and happy, and I actually felt good about myself. She told me I was conceited. I don't think she was trying to send mixed signals, but I was very confused and felt I couldn't win no matter what I did.
As a teenager, criticism would send me into a spiral of self-hatred and depression. It was hard and miserable for me and for my mom. She hated seeing me that way.
Many of us grew up under constant criticism. Without realizing it, those same words can slip into how we speak to our children. If we don’t pause and reflect, we risk raising kids who live for approval—or worse, kids who grow self-focused and entitled. Ironically, criticism can breed both extremes. Balanced, godly truth can help change the whole situation.
Scripture Anchor:
“Death and life are in the power of the tongue, and those who love it will eat its fruit.” (Proverbs 18:21, NKJV)

Criticism can breed two extremes in children: shame or pride. Both are seeds of narcissistic, self-focused attitudes. Parents who grew up with criticism often pass it down—but by pivoting, you can break the cycle.
God healed me of the terrible battle with depression I had in college. The three step pivot is what he showed me, and it has worked for years now with me and others I know.
3-Step Pivot:
Catch the Criticism. What thought are you replaying or what event/criticism triggered a spiral?
Counter with Truth. Pray and find a scripture that cancels it. Often 2 Corinthians 10:5 comes to mind for me and helps tremendously.
Choose an Outward Act. Serve someone else immediately. This is key. As we turn our focus to others, we destroy the Enemy's methods and plan. We let go of our weakness and allow the Holy Spirit to work in and through our lives.
If we are still replaying the criticisms of the past, we need to pray about forgiveness. We must allow God to examine our hearts and see if we are holding onto bitterness. Are we holding on to something that isn't ours to own? Maybe someone has been critical or even hostile in our past, but after letting the Holy Spirit shine light into the situation, we realize the other person was out of line. So, we need to let it go when that is the case. We need to forgive and pray for them, but then we need to move on.
Through forgiveness, we can find healing and wholeness and be ready to parent from a healthy place.

Parenting After the Pivot
Once we've mastered our own emotions and pasts, we have to tackle the very tricky prospect of parenting. Let's face it, we're wrestling with one of the most nuanced challenges in Christian parenting - forming children who are both humble and confident, grounded in their God-given worth without becoming prideful. This balance requires moving beyond both harsh criticism and empty praise toward something deeper. Are you ready to dive in?
(As we walk through this, we can apply these truths to our own hearts and lives. We can let them minister to us as well.)
Biblical Foundation for Healthy Identity
The core scriptural principle is that our children's identity comes from being image-bearers of God (Genesis 1:27) and beloved children of the Father (1 John 3:1). This gives them inherent worth that isn't earned through performance or destroyed by failure. Here are a few other key verses:
Psalm 139:13-16 - God knit them together, knows them intimately
Ephesians 2:10 - they are God's workmanship, created for good works
Jeremiah 1:5 - God knew them before they were formed
These verses help us create what you might call "gospel-centered confidence" - security rooted in God's love rather than personal achievement or others' opinions. Let that wash over your heart. I don't know about you, but I find freedom and peace in these verses and these realizations. I hope you do too.
Some Practical Approaches for Parents
In addition to truth, as parents, we desperately need some practical pointers and practices we can implement immediately. Here are a few:
Praise Character Over Performance: Instead of "You're so smart!" try "I see how hard you worked on that problem" or "You showed real kindness when you helped your sister." This builds internal motivation rather than dependence on external validation.
Acknowledge Struggles Without Shaming: When children fail or sin, address it as "This isn't who God created you to be" rather than "You always mess up." Please, please, please, don't refer to sin as a mistake. Sin is a willful choice we make in our human desires and selfishness. A mistake is not willful or sinful. It is just a mistake because we are not perfect. Help them see mistakes as growth opportunities, not identity markers and not shameful.
Model Healthy Self-Assessment: Let children see you acknowledging both your strengths (as gifts from God) and areas for growth without self-condemnation. Show them what it looks like to receive correction gracefully. We are also modeling humility and teachability in doing this - all are powerful, essential lessons in discipleship and self-discipline.
Focus on Heart Posture: Teach children to ask "How can I serve?" rather than "How can I succeed?" This cultivates the humility Christ demonstrated while still encouraging them to use their gifts boldly. It is a mind shift that honors God and builds the heart and character of our children while also "immunizing" them from the depression spiral.
For Parents Overcoming Critical Backgrounds
Parents who grew up with harsh criticism often swing too far toward praise to compensate. The healing path involves recognizing that building identity on anything other than God's love - whether criticism or excessive affirmation - creates insecurity and self-focused thinking. Consider how Proverbs balances correction with love (Proverbs 3:11-12) and how Jesus both affirmed people's worth and called them to growth.
The goal is raising children who can say with Paul, "But by the grace of God I am what I am, and his grace toward me was not in vain. On the contrary, I worked harder than any of them, though it was not I, but the grace of God that is with me." (1 Corinthians 15:10 ESV) - confident in their calling without being boastful, secure enough to serve others rather than constantly seeking validation.
This requires us as parents to do our own heart work, allowing God to heal our critical inner voices so we can speak life over our children from a place of gospel security rather than our own unmet needs.
With God's grace, wisdom, and healing, we can break the criticism spiral for our children and for ourselves. God is a God of victory and growth. He's not giving up on us, so let's stay strong and courageous building a legacy of faith.

Journal Prompts for Parents:
What old words or moments of criticism still play in my mind?
How do they show up in how I react to my children?
Do I own this—or is this someone else’s problem?
Is this valid—or just a reflection of the other person’s brokenness?
What truth from God’s Word replaces it?
Every word you shift plants new seeds. As you heal, you speak life into your children, helping them grow into secure, Christ-centered adults.
